Reconciling Faith and Reason in Kabbalah

The Two Arks of Knowing

Humanity's quest for truth has often been framed as a timeless battle between two opposing forces: faith and reason. We are taught to see tradition and inquiry as locked in a struggle for dominance. Within the deep streams of Jewish mysticism, however, this conflict is reframed not as a war to be won, but as a partnership to be understood. The two primary paths to knowing God—Kabbalah (literally, "that which is received," or faith in divine tradition) and Chakira (intellectual investigation or philosophical inquiry)—are seen as complementary, yet hierarchical, modes of apprehending reality. How, then, do these seemingly divergent paths converge, and which one provides the ultimate foundation for a spiritual life?

Key Highlights

• The Two Paths to Truth: Jewish thought recognizes two fundamental ways of engaging with the divine: Kabbalah, the path of received tradition and unwavering faith, and Chakira, the path of intellectual inquiry and reason.

• The Parable of the Two Arks: A profound rabbinic parable illustrates this dynamic with the image of two arks traveling together: one containing a corpse and the other the Divine Presence. This symbolizes the relationship between reason and faith, where true worldly accomplishment (the corpse) is only validated by its fulfillment of divine tradition (the Divine Presence).

• The Primacy of Faith: When a conclusion from intellectual inquiry contradicts a commandment received through tradition, faith (Kabbalah) must always take precedence. The rite of circumcision demonstrates that the divine command stands even when a rational explanation for it is no longer applicable.

• The Limits of Intellect: A powerful parable of a blind man challenging a philosopher to explain fire reveals that pure reason is incapable of grasping phenomena that lie beyond direct experience. This underscores the necessity of accepting truths that transcend empirical or intellectual proof.

• Three Realms of Knowledge: True wisdom involves discerning where to apply each path. Divine and supernatural matters demand faith; mundane, natural phenomena invite inquiry; and in matters of Torah, inquiry may be used to adorn and illuminate faith, but never to supplant it.

• 
  

Deconstructing the Paths to Truth

The Two Camps: Kabbalah vs. Chakira

For generations, sages have debated the proper way to serve God. One camp champions the path of Chakira, or intellectual inquiry, believing that one must strive to understand the divine through logic and reason. The other, however, warns that this path is fraught with peril. They argue for the way of Kabbalah—unquestioning faith in the tradition passed down from generation to generation.

This latter group cautions that "most who go down that [path of inquiry] do not return," becoming lost in intellectual traps. They hold fast to the principle, "In what is more wondrous than you, do not probe; in what is concealed from you, do not investigate." For them, the correct path is to accept the commandments as an immutable law—chukat haTorah—and to seek knowledge from the wellspring of tradition, as it is written, "Ask your father, and he will tell you; your elders, and they will say to you." This sets the stage for a fundamental tension: is God found primarily through the mind or through the soul's faithful acceptance?

The Parable of the Two Arks

A powerful teaching from the Talmud offers a key to resolving this tension. It describes a striking scene from the Israelites' journey through the desert:

As a kind of symbol, all those years that Israel was in the desert, two arks—one of a corpse and one of the Divine Presence—would travel with one another. Passersby would ask, "What is the nature of these two arks?" They would be told, "One is of a corpse, and one is of the Divine Presence." They would then ask, "And what is the way of a corpse to travel with the Divine Presence?" And the answer was given: "This one [the corpse] fulfilled all that is written in that one [the Divine Presence]."

The mystical interpretation of this parable is profound. The "ark of the Divine Presence" represents Kabbalah—the living, transcendent, and unshakeable truth received through divine tradition. The "ark of the corpse" represents the fruits of Chakira—the tangible, intellectually derived, and worldly accomplishments of a person.

On the surface, the two seem incompatible. What has the static, lifeless world of human achievement to do with the living presence of God? The answer lies in their ultimate relationship. A life of intellectual pursuit and worldly action is only sanctified when it is dedicated to fulfilling the divine will. The "corpse" is worthy of traveling with the "Divine Presence" only because its entire existence was a testament to the principles contained within the sacred ark of faith. Reason finds its ultimate purpose not in challenging faith, but in serving it.

When Intellect Must Yield: The Case of Circumcision

The primacy of faith over reason is not merely theoretical; it is embedded in Jewish law and practice. Consider the commandment of circumcision (milah) on the eighth day. The great mystic Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai offered a beautiful intellectual reason for this timing: it allows the mother a full seven days to undergo ritual purification so that she can be pure on the night of the eighth day, enabling both parents to rejoice fully in the commandment together.

This is a powerful insight derived from Chakira. Yet, it is not the foundation of the law. What if the mother gives birth in a state that prevents her from purifying herself by the eighth day? If the intellectual reason were the primary cause, one would have to delay the circumcision. But the law is clear: the child is to be circumcised on the eighth day regardless.

Here, the law derived from Kabbalah—the received tradition from Sinai—overrides the beautiful but conditional reason supplied by intellect. The command of faith is absolute. The intellectual insight serves to adorn and beautify the commandment when circumstances permit, but it can never be the reason to set it aside. Faith provides the unshakeable structure; reason is the elegant ornamentation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Kabbalah and Chakira?

Kabbalah literally means "that which is received" and refers to the path of knowledge through divine tradition and faith. Chakira means "investigation" and refers to the path of knowledge through intellectual inquiry, philosophy, and reason.

Which path is considered superior in Jewish mysticism?

The path of Kabbalah, or faith in received tradition, is considered the foundational and superior path. When a conclusion drawn from Chakira (reason) conflicts with a principle of Kabbalah, faith always takes precedence.

What is the meaning of the parable of the two arks?

The parable illustrates the ideal relationship between a life of action and intellect (the "ark of the corpse") and a life of faith (the "ark of the Divine Presence"). It teaches that worldly accomplishments are only validated and sanctified when they are used to fulfill the commandments and principles contained within the divine tradition.

How does the example of circumcision illustrate the relationship between faith and reason?

The commandment to perform circumcision on the eighth day is absolute and based on received tradition (Kabbalah). An intellectual reason, such as allowing the parents to rejoice together in purity, is a beautiful insight but is secondary. If that reason is absent, the commandment of faith still stands, demonstrating that faith is the unconditional foundation and reason is a conditional adornment.

Is intellectual inquiry ever encouraged?

Yes. The sources encourage using intellectual inquiry to understand natural phenomena not explicitly detailed in the Torah, such as the workings of a telegraph or a phonograph. It is seen as a tool to appreciate the world God created, but it is not the proper tool for apprehending divine, supernatural truths, which must be accepted through faith.

A Unified Path to Truth

The mystical tradition teaches that faith and reason are not adversaries in a zero-sum game, but partners in a sacred dance. Kabbalah, the path of received tradition, provides the unshakeable foundation—the "what" of divine will that gives life its ultimate meaning and direction. Chakira, the path of inquiry, is the tool given to us to explore and understand the "how" of the physical world God created and, at times, to find beautiful adornments for the commandments we observe. It can illuminate faith, but it can never replace it. True wisdom lies not in choosing one over the other, but in knowing which path to walk in the different realms of our existence.

If the highest wisdom lies not in choosing between faith and reason, but in understanding how each finds its proper place, what other perceived conflicts in our lives might be resolved through a similar synthesis?